My gelato obsession – how to find the best gelato

My gelato obsession – how to find the best gelato

I tasted my first proper gelato on the banks of Lake Garda, Italy, in the pretty town of Sirmione.

It was a far cry from the whipped up sugary technicolour mess that passed for gelato in my childhood. This version was creamy and full of flavour. I wanted to savour every mouthful.

badiani gelato florence

These days gelato is probably my main weakness. I just can’t resist the smooth texture and density of flavour that you get from savouring flavours that have been properly made.

What I love about gelato

Ice-cream and sorbet are delicious but they don’t match the experience. I love the creamy milky based varieties, the intense chocolate kind, fruit based, traditional and modern flavours and mash ups.. yes all of it.

On a recent trip to Italy I had to restrain myself from enjoying more than two serves of the ice cold goodness a day.. I won’t say how big they were either. Italians are so civilised that they eat gelato at pretty much any time of day, probably even for breakfast. So who was I to buck tradition.

What is gelato?

What is it about gelato that makes it so delicious? I made a little cheat sheet for you but the three main factors are: the percentage of butterfat in the mixture, the process of combining ingredients and the temperature at which the mixture is stored.

Gelato - a guide to flavours and why it differs from icecream

Where to find the world’s best gelato

United Kingdom

Hands down one of the best examples of creamy authentic gelato I have tried was at Badiani gelateria at Mercato Metropolitano in London’s Elephant and Castle. Badiani are a Florentine company who have been making gelato since 1936. Their emphasis is on the best and purest ingredients. You can taste that commitment to quality in every lick.

Recently in Brighton I had a chocolatey scoop of nutella and another of salted caramel from a traditional Italian style shop and then I spied Gelato Gusto. They do all sorts of interesting flavours and quirky things including a gelato burger! Oh no! Luckily the queue was way too long for my poor little toddlers to manage otherwise my jeans would be in extreme protest right now.

lemon gelato

Barcelona, Spain

Hot days in Barcelona lend themselves to the fruitier gelato flavours. Look no further than Gelaaati di Marco behind the cathedral. You must try the Mojito flavour. It is so refreshing and minty. I tried it several years ago and am still talking about it. It was that good.

Sydney and Melbourne, Australia

Meanwhile back home in Melbourne it seems our house is nicely wedged between the two Gelato Messina outlets in Fitzroy and Richmond. So when we return I will be in frozen heaven.

Headquartered in Sydney, Messina has queues out the door most nights at all their branches. Their reputation is justified by their quality and selection. At this gelateria you will find 35 classic flavours and five special flavours each week.

I am always tempted by the specials with names like “Bishop of Ken” which is a vanilla anglaise gelato with rhubarb and oat crumble.


I really encourage you to keep an open mind when it comes to sourcing the best gelato in Italy.

The hipster places may look great but they may not have the yummiest product. When sourcing your gelaterie look for the following signs – produzione artigianale  or proprio produzione means that the gelato is made by the owners of the shop.

But my top tip for finding great gelato is to avoid places where the gelato is on display in glass cabinets. The gelato cannot stay at the right temperature in those conditions.

Another tell tale sign is bright, unnatural colours of gelato. Look for the pistachio flavour. If it is bright green then move on. Proper pistachio gelato is a pale greeny brown colour.

In Florence try La Strega Nocciola and Badiani

We found a tiny little bar in Bagni di Lucca out of the main tourist route that made the creamiest, most intense flavours. The giveaway that they had some serious gelato making credentials was their certificate from the Gelato University.

Oh yes, there is such a thing. I think I’ll do a PHD!

Help a gelato lover out.. where have you eaten the most amazing gelato? What food experiences have defined your travels?


Subscribe to Untold Morsels

Subscribe to receive our monthly newsletter full of inspirational ideas for memorable trips.

As a thank you we will send you a FREE checklist for booking the best holiday accommodation rental apartments and villas on, AirBnB etc

Powered by ConvertKit


  1. 16th August 2016 / 2:45 PM

    Coincidentally, some of the best gelato I’ve ever had has also come along the banks of Lake Garda, although the name of the town escapes me. They really are kings at it over in that part of the world

  2. 16th August 2016 / 8:53 PM

    I love gelato also. Have been to Garda lake and very likely had gelato there. Still do not remember anything specific. I mostly take my chances with different results. I hardly remember my food experiences in detail with very few exceptions. Thanks for sharing Katy. I loved it!

    • 17th August 2016 / 8:24 AM

      Ooh I get so annoyed when I waste calories and money on bad food especially bad gelato! Thanks for stopping by Anita

  3. 17th August 2016 / 6:38 PM

    As I live in Barcelona, I’ll have to check out that Gelateria! Thanks for bringing that to my attention! I do love a good gelato!

    • 17th August 2016 / 10:54 PM

      You must check out Gelaaati – I cant stop thinking about the mojito flavour now!

  4. 20th August 2016 / 1:17 PM

    There’s tiny shop just off the square in Capri that has the most-to-die-for strawberries and cream gelato. I still dream about it. And I’ve not seen anywhere else with that flavour – perhaps a regional specialty? The shop also made its own waffle cones on the spot pretty much as they were serving the gelato. Best flavour and cones ever!!!

    • 20th August 2016 / 1:59 PM

      Ooh that sounds incredible.. hopefully we will make it there next year

  5. 17th March 2017 / 9:49 PM

    I lived in Pisa for a while and there was a great gelateria next to the river in the centre of the city, I went there frequently..! Am off to Sicily next month so I’ll do a bit of research for you…

    • 18th March 2017 / 4:18 PM

      We are in Sicily in April too! Let’s swap notes 🙂

      • 19th March 2017 / 8:02 PM

        Where are you heading? I’ve just been reading up on Mt Etna, really hope it will still be erupting next month!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *